A Guide to Reference Checks

A Guide to Reference Checks

Don’t make the rookie mistake of cutting corners with reference checks – it’s a sure-fire way to wind up with a nightmare tenant. A three-minute read.

When it comes to tenant selection, there’s a saying that all landlords should heed: Go with the right tenant, not the first tenant.
 
Sometimes, landlords are so eager to see rent payments rolling in that they treat the reference checking process as a tick-box exercise rather than an investigative one.
 
But rushing to greenlight the first person willing to take your property can come back to haunt you.
 
What do reference checks involve?
It’s a complex process (for a full list get in touch with us here at MILLBANKS), but key aspects include:
·        ID checks (to make sure the candidate is who they say they are)
  • Credit history
  • References from previous landlords and current employer
 
Credit checks
County court judgments and unpaid debts are obvious red flags, but it’s important to delve deeper than that. You need to review a candidate’s full credit report and get a clear overview of their financial commitments and history.
 
What kind of outgoings do they have regarding credit cards, loans, and bills? It may be that technically the candidate can afford the rent, but with their other debt repayments, it would be a serious squeeze.
 
Also, examine their track record when it comes to paying bills. A history of late payments suggests that they’re disorganised with their finances – bad news if you want the rent paid on time.
 
Landlord references
References from a candidate’s previous landlords are useful – up to a point. We know of cases where a landlord has written a troublesome tenant a good reference just to get shot of them (not ethical, but it happens).
 
If you have doubts about a candidate’s suitability, don’t let a positive landlord reference be the deciding factor in giving them a property.
 
Employer references
It’s important to check a candidate’s salary with their employer, but don’t take a company email at face value (sometimes people get a ‘mate’ in HR to inflate their earnings).
 
Ask to see payslips and bank statements and ring the employer yourself to verify the accuracy of the email’s contents.
 
Top tip
Gambling on a risky tenant can turn out to be a costly decision – so invest time and energy in the tenant referencing process.
 
Get a good letting agent on board if you’d like an expert to handle it for you.
Give us a call
 
Contact us here at MILLBANKS on (01953) 453838 or drop us an e-mail to lettings@millbanks.com to learn more about our property management services.



Get in touch with us

If you’re planning to sell in early 2026, now is the time to understand the timeline, the preparation and the steps that will help you move smoothly from listing to completion.

Thinking of selling your Attleborough home? New data shows it takes an average of 57 days to find a buyer — but this varies widely by property type and price. With just under half of homes failing to sell, smart pricing and strong marketing are key to securing the best result in today’s market.

Over the past decade, Attleborough’s property market has painted a vibrant picture of change. Our latest map reveals how different parts of the town have grown — from modest rises in some areas to striking surges in others. Discover how your street fits into Attleborough’s evolving story of house prices and local value.

Being a landlord in 2025 comes with fresh challenges, from shifting regulations to changing tenant expectations. Whether you’re experienced or new to lettings, this checklist will help you stay compliant, competitive, and confident in the year ahead.